I'm asking you to do an unpleasant thing for a decent motive. You don't want to do it, and I understand how you feel, but I'm trying to get you to see that your personal moral code isn't always the highest factor. In wartime, a soldier shoots to kill because the universe imposes that situation on him. It may be an unjust war, and that might be his brother in the ship he's aiming at, but the war is real and he has his role.”
"Where's the room for free will in this mechanical universe of yours, Charles?”
"There isn't any. That's why I say the universe stinks.”
"We have no freedom at all?”
"The freedom to wriggle a little on the hook.”
"Have you felt this way all your life?”
"Most of it,” Boardman said.
"When you were my age? (Robert Silverberg)

I'm asking you to do an unpleasant thing for a decent motive. You don't want to do it, and I understand how you feel, but I'm trying to get you to see that your personal moral code isn't always the highest factor. In wartime, a soldier shoots to kill because the universe imposes that situation on him. It may be an unjust war, and that might be his brother in the ship he's aiming at, but the war is real and he has his role.” "Where's the room for free will in this mechanical universe of yours, Charles?” "There isn't any. That's why I say the universe stinks.” "We have no freedom at all?” "The freedom to wriggle a little on the hook.” "Have you felt this way all your life?” "Most of it,” Boardman said. "When you were my age?

Robert Silverberg

Related topics

age aiming asking brother code factor felt free freedom hook kill life might mechanical moral motive personal real role room say see ship situation soldier thing trying universe war way wriggle charles boardman wartime shoots stinks

Related quotes