The Islanders have had two penalty shots in Stanley Cup playoff history, here is number 3. Bates against Joseph...... Bates in on goal.... he shoots, He scores! Consider that for a franchise loaded with memorable postseason moments, you have just witnessed one of the most memorable. A penalty shot goal by Shawn Bates to give the Islanders a 4–3 lead with 2 minutes and 30 seconds left in regulation time.